Monday, March 14, 2016

Where Was Sanders on Health Care in '93 and '94? Against the Clintons.

Surely you've heard by now what Hillary Clinton had to say about Bernie Sanders and health care reform in the 1990s:
And you've probably seen the photo or video of Sanders standing behind Clinton in a 1993 speech on the subject (above) as well as these thankful words from the same year:
The optics of this, admittedly, aren't flattering to Hillary and she should have been more careful with her wording of the criticism. But none of the pushback really answers her point: Just where was Bernie when the Clintons were trying to pass health care reform?

Having listened to Sanders on the campaign trail for the past year or so, my guess is that he wanted single-payer and wouldn't compromise, therefore being not much help to the Clintons as they were fighting like hell for the Health Security Act well into 1994.

But it turns out that none of us have to guess, because Sanders himself wrote about it in his 1997 memoir Outsider in the House (later renamed and re-released in 2015 as Outsider in the White House):

So by his own admission, Bernie Sanders didn't support the Clinton health care initiative (which had a shot at passing) and instead backed a single-payer plan (which had zero chance at passing).

And now we know why Hillary Clinton said what she did the other day.

The White House needed every single Democratic (and democratic socialist) vote that they could get in order to have any shot at making health care reform a reality. Clearly Hillary was trying to woo Bernie's support, as she surely did with so many others in Congress, but it ultimately didn't work. In the end, Sanders wouldn't compromise, wouldn't support their plan, and ultimately wasn't much help to the Clintons.

But it doesn't stop there. In the same excerpt, he then blames the Health Security Act's failure solely on lobbying and ad spending by the insurance companies rather than a lack of votes for it in Congress! Did he really, seriously believe that there wouldn't have been a similar (or likely far worse) opposition effort if single-payer had a real shot at becoming law? Please. 

He doesn't sound too bothered that 'Hillarycare' went up in flames, does he? It wasn't his thing, the insurance companies shot it down anyway, and that's that. But to his credit, perhaps he learned something...because he did end up supporting President Obama's similarly "complicated and compromised" Affordable Care Act in '09 and '10.

Whatever the case, it looks like we have an answer to the question of where Bernie Sanders was on health care reform in '93 and '94: Against the Clintons.


UPDATE: Just three hours after this was published, the Huffington Post has independently confirmed Hillary HQ's report.
But his presence at that speech -- like a gracious letter Clinton sent him in 1993 -- isn't proof that Sanders was a major ally of the Clinton health care effort. Sanders wasn’t even endorsing the Clinton plan, unlike another member of Congress who attended the rally.
And an internal memo from the Bill Clinton administration shows that the White House was worried that Sanders might hold out. "Given his reputation for independence and his more combative style [he] may be of the more difficult members to get on board the Administration’s proposal,” the memo said.
In fact, Sanders opposed the proposal throughout the process, his campaign confirmed to The Huffington Post. As late as August 1994, while Democrats were making a last-ditch effort to pass Clinton’s plan, Sanders held a press conference opposing it -- and touting single-payer, according to his campaign.
Sanders' commitment, or lack thereof, to the White House plan wasn't a cause of its failure, considering staunch resistance from the health care industry, Republicans and conservative Democrats. But Clinton clearly hasn't forgotten it.


  1. One reason why he will never get anything done.


      Bernie gets it done in Congress!

      Bernie’s achievements from an early age.

    2. Oh good. Glad M William came in like a Bernie Borg to patch up the reality breach. Well done, Seven of Stupid.

    3. And it was Sanders, by opposing the AUMF, who voted FOR war.

      Though he lies about it today.

      Tax return release score:

      Clinton tax return release: 33 YEARS.

      Sanders tax return release: 1 (the same 1 TWICE).

      Yet we are to believe Sanders that it is Clinton who has something to hide.

  2. You cannot say that "Sanders' commitment, or lack thereof, to the White House plan wasn't a cause of its failure..." His opposition was instrumental in fostering its defeat. In fact, I don't believe it was Sanders' "unyielding principles." This is naive, nonsense.

    1. He co-sponsored the legislation. I guess that somehow equals opposing it, in fantasyland.

    2. He co-sponsored the legislation. I guess that somehow equals opposing it, in fantasyland.

    3. But VOTED AGAINST it.


  3. Why am I not surprised that a candidate without principles also has supporters with scruples?

  4. Taking care of the skin has become a feature of concern to every person especially today where much attention is given to the beauty of the skin. It is common today to see people doing all sorts of actions to take care of their skins through the use of various skin care components. The skin should often be considered as an essential component that boosters your attractiveness especially to onlookers.essential oil diffuser hq

  5. Hi there,

    Just saw this on DK, and I am wondering...your home page says you are a progressive blog. Are you also saying that the Clinton health care plan was more progressive than a single payer?

    1. No. But Hillarycare was attainable in '94. Single payer was not. Sanders had to have it his way and was no help to the Clintons on this.So we had to wait 16 years for Obamacare to basically do the same thing. Luckily, Sanders did help with that.

    2. The facts substantiate this obvious fact:

      The Clinton plan could have been passed had Sanders supported.

      "Single payer" had no chance of passage.

      So Sanders voted AGAINST the Clinton plan because it wasn't the bill that WOULD NOT pass.

      Not-so-by-the-way: How did Sanders' "Single Payer" work in his state of Vermont? It FAILED.

      But his siding and voting with the right-wing/Republicans and NRA to protect the gun corporations was successful.

  6. In the rural areas, people continued to live and die without ever seeing a nurse much less a physician because health care was absent or inaccesible, physically and financially. Go Here

  7. They found the introduce of their study on watching Japanese ladies who are more prominent than-normal green tea consumers; have bring down death rates contrasted with others.see here

  8. This comment has been removed by the author.